THE CABIN IN
THE woods

HOME FEO'S STORE REVIEWS INTERVIEWS FEO AMANTE THEATER SCIENCE MOMENT UNFAIR RACIAL CLICHÉ ALERT


I THOUGHT
OF IT FIRST!
Feo Amante April 15, 2015 Report
E.C.McMullen Jr.
Cabin in the Woods
CABIN IN THE WOODS
MOVIE REVIEW
CRAP IN THE CABIN
NEWS
THE CABIN IN THE WOODS IS BASED UPON A SINGLE ORIGINAL IDEA?

SERIOUSLY?

It's nothing new in Hollywood. If any movie is successful, the filmmakers are going to be sued by someone claiming that it was based on their story, movie, whatever.

Sometimes these lawsuits are legitimate and major studios have knowingly stole from a writer, thereby shaving the expense of $50,000 off their $150 million movie.

Or you know, a week of craft services. Such business acumen among the major studios is legendary, and sometimes the studios lose.

However, most of these suits are frauds.

Right now Joss Whedon and Drew Goddard are being sued for their parody, THE CABIN IN THE WOODS.

The 2012 movie was meant to be a riff on every Cabin or House In the Woods story, novel, and movie ever made.

House On Haunted HillFor those of you unfamiliar with such a motif, let me point out William Castle's 1959 opus, THE HOUSE ON HAUNTED HILL.
Or Francis Ford Coppola's first Horror film (for Roger Corman no less), DEMENTIA 13. If 1963's DEMENTIA 13, or 1963's THE HAUNTING is too far back for you, how about 1967's SPIDER BABY?
Or 1968's NIGHT OF THE LIVING DEAD?
1971's A BAY OF BLOOD?
1973's LISA AND THE DEVIL?
1974's THE TEXAS CHAINSAW MASSACRE?
1975's THE ROCKY HORROR PICTURE SHOW (which was a musical spoof of the stereotypical Cabin/House In The Woods type movies of its time - over 40 years ago)?
1977's THE HILLS HAVE EYES?
1979's THE EVIL DEAD?
1980's FRIDAY THE 13th?
1999's THE BLAIR WITCH PROJECT?
2002's CABIN FEVER?
2003's WRONG TURN?

So despite the fact that Cabin/House in the Woods/Rural area with redneck varmints afflicting strangers/outsiders is a standard Horror motif every bit as common as vampires and zombies (did I mention 1971's STRAW DOGS? 2006's THE HILLS HAVE EYES? How about 1978's I SPIT ON YOUR GRAVE?), author Peter Gallagher (not to be confused with the actor who starred in 1999's THE HOUSE ON HAUNTED HILL) is suing the two men for copyright infringement. Peter says that THE CABIN IN THE WOODS steals the premise - The Premise - of his self-published 2006 book, THE LITTLE WHITE TRIP: A Night in the Pines.

Okay then, so what is that premise?

According to Gallagher's complaint (court document supplied by The Hollywood Reporter), these are the similarities,
27. Like the Book, the Film tells the story of five friends (three males and two females) between the ages of 17 and 22 who take a take a trip to a remote cabin in the woods."

I have to stop here because that premise is so astoundingly similar to (might one go so far as to say stolen from?) bestselling author, Richard Laymon's 1980 novel, THE CELLAR.
Or Laymon's 1981 novel, THE WOODS ARE DARK.
Or his 1983 novel, NIGHTMARE LAKE.
As well as Laymon's 1986 novel, THE BEAST HOUSE, 1988 novel MIDNIGHT'S LAIR, not to mention... you know what? Just take it as a given that the first paragraph in Gallagher's complaint describing his premise is similar to nearly all of Richard Laymon's bibliography, which has been on the market for the last 35 years.

If you haven't read them, then you should.

Let's continue.

Betting board

"The cabin's previous inhabitants were murdered by the father of the family, who returns to terrorize the group of friends."

Not to be confused with the similarity to the father of the twin girls in Stephen King's 1977 novel, THE SHINING. Or

"Throughout, the friends are being filmed and manipulated by persons behind the scenes, inadvertently playing characters in a real-life horror show."

Not to be confused with MTVs FEAR, which ran from 2000 to 2002. Or 2003's THE LAST HORROR MOVIE.

"The cabin in the book is referred to as the "Brinkley Cabin" and in the film it is the "Buckner Cabin.""

Later in the same complaint, Peter changes the cabin from its referred-to name, "Brinkley cabin" to "Brinkley House." when he writes,

4. The cabin the protagonists are going to is referred to as the "Brinkley house."

the Legend of Hell HouseWhich is not unlike the house in Richard Matheson's 1971 novel, HELL HOUSE being referred to as "Belasco House". HELL HOUSE was later made into the 1973 movie, THE LEGEND OF HELL HOUSE.

Is the press reporting this correctly? Is Peter really trying to credit himself with creating the Cabin In The Woods subgenre?

Now let's encapsulate.

Peter Gallagher's 2006 novel, THE LITTLE WHITE TRIP: A Night in the Pines, is about five young friends who go to a cabin in the woods where they are terrorized by a killer and, unbeknownst to them, are manipulated and recorded for a show.

That's the exact plot of the 2002 Horror movie, MY LITTLE EYE, starring Bradley Cooper and written and produced by David Hilton. Filming and directing a person or persons without their knowledge to make a movie or show also smacks directly of 1968's THE SECRET CINEMA, 1983's SWEET GANG, 1998's THE TRUMAN SHOW, 1999's BOWFINGER, and TV's long running (15 years) Candid Camera.

And of course, there's Robert Dunbar's NYT bestseller and award winning novel and "Cabin in the Woods" type Horror trilogy which began with 1989's THE PINES.

Based upon Peter Gallagher's complaint, oh yeah, his work was entirely original.

If anything, I'm flabbergasted that anyone would try and make the claim that a satire like THE CABIN IN THE WOODS is largely based upon any single story. Everything from CREATURE FROM THE BLACK LAGOON to HELLRAISER was thrown in there for good measure.

Gallagher wants $10 million from the combination of Whedon, Drew, Whedon's company, Mutant Enemy, and Lionsgate.

Read more about it at THR.

Sept. 14, 2015 UPDATE -

Case Dismissed!

"While the two works share a common premise of students travelling to remote locations and subsequently being murdered, real or otherwise, that premise is unprotectable. The concept of young people venturing off to such locations and being murdered by some evil force is common in horror films."
- U.S. District Judge Otis D. Wright II

Now writer Peter Gallagher, the woefully confused plaintiff (to put it kinder than it needs to be) has likely wrecked any writing career he could have ever had, and all over his immense foolishness.

End Skull
END

WHAT TO WEAR?
the Cabin in the Woods The Thing Firefly
THE CABIN IN THE WOODS
MOVIE REVIEW
CRAP IN THE WOODS
POSTER ARTICLE
SAVE FIREFLY
ORIGINAL 2002 ARTICLE
FEO AMANTE'S HORROR THRILLER
Created by:
E.C.MULLEN JR.
COME FOLLOW ME @
Amazon
ECMJr
Feo Blog
IMDb
Stage32
Twitter
YouTube
Zazzle Shop
FEO'S BRAGGADOCIO

The ScientistFeo and Cup #118Some people think I'm more important than you (I don't, but they do. You know how they are) and this is their (HA!) evidence.

INTERVIEWS
Joe Mynhardt interviews E.C. McMullen Jr. in the book HORROR 201: The Silver Scream.

Matt Jarbo's interview with Feo Amante at The Zurvivalist.

James Cheetham's Q&A with Feo Amante at Unconventional Interviews *.

Megan Scudellari interviews Feo Amante and Kelly Parks (of THE SCIENCE MOMENT) in The Scientist Magazine.

Check out our interview at The-Scientist.com.

REFERENCES
Anthropologist Gretchen Bakke, PhD, references my UNFAIR RACIAL CLICHE ALERT as an expert resource in her 2010 Anthropological Quarterly essay @ Johns Hopkins University

Researcher David Waldron, references my review of UNDERWORLD in the Spring 2005, Journal of Religion and Popular Culture entry, Role-Playing Games and the Christian Right: Community Formation in Response to a Moral Panic (downloadable pdf).

E.C. McMullen Jr.
Author page at Amazon (Amazon.com)
Listed at GoodReads
Internet Movie Database resume (IMDb.com),
Stage 32 listing (stage32.com),
Listed at Academia.edu and is a
19 year member of the San Diego Comic Convention (SDCC).
Wikipedia 1, 2, 3, 4
Starbucks Cup #118
E.C. McMullen Jr. / Feo Amante is quoted throughout the Internet and print as a resource on,

Books That Bounce Inspiration from Shivers?*
Cirque Du Freak My Weekend of Horrors*
FilmSchoolRejects The Science of Fiction
In Defense Of J.J. Abrams PHANTASM EXHUMED: The Unauthorized Companion

*Linked to archive.org

NEWS?
SUBMISSIONS?
Read:
SUBMISSION GUIDELINES

WHO IS FEO AMANTE?

WHO SAID WHAT?

FAIR USE -

PRIVACY POLICY -

OWNERSHIP -

CONTACT

Feo Amante bannerFeo Amante's Horror Home Page, Feo Amante's Horror Thriller, World's Oldest Active Horror website, horrorthriller.com, and feoamante.com are owned and Copyright 1997 - 2023 by E.C.McMullen Jr. All images and text belong to E.C.McMullen Jr. unless otherwise noted.
All fiction stories belong to their individual authors. THANKS FOR READING!